Kitchen Secret · Cooking Tips

How to Make Kaymak at Home and Get the Right Consistency

Canberk AkyürekAşçı Yamağı
18 February 2026 Last updated: 10 September 2026 66 reads 2 comments

For kaymak, use whole milk, preferably buffalo or cow’s milk; keep the milk just below boiling over low heat and simmer it gently for 45–60 minutes. Do not stir it during this time; let a thick layer form on top. After simmering, let the pot cool, then leave it in the refrigerator overnight. This allows the top layer to firm enough to cut and lift with a knife. Homemade kaymak turns out better when made in a wide, shallow pot; the larger surface area helps the fat rise and form a thick layer. The same amount of milk in a narrow, deep pot produces a much thinner layer.

Which milk should be used for kaymak?

A thick layer of kaymak will not form without high-fat milk; therefore, whole milk is essential. Using reduced-fat or skim milk will produce almost no result. Buffalo milk traditionally makes the richest and thickest kaymak because it has a higher fat content.

Pasteurized fresh milk can also be used, but the fresher the milk, the more pronounced and mildly sweet the flavor of the kaymak.

How long should the milk be simmered?

First bring the milk to a boil over medium heat, then lower the heat and keep it at a gentle simmer for 45–60 minutes. Leave the pot uncovered during this time so moisture can evaporate and the milk can thicken.

If the time is too short, the milk will not thicken enough and the layer will be quite thin; if it is too long, the milk may stick to the bottom, so it is important to keep the heat genuinely low.

How does the kaymak layer form, and why should it not be stirred?

Fat molecules on the surface of the milk rise with the heat and form a thin membrane; over time, this membrane thickens into kaymak. Stirring breaks up the layer that has formed and mixes it back into the milk, so the kaymak will not collect again at the same thickness.

While the pot is simmering, adjust the heat only to prevent boil-over and do not touch the milk with a spoon; this lets the layer thicken in stages without being disturbed.

How long does kaymak take to set, and how should it be chilled?

After simmering, first let the pot cool at room temperature, then, within 2 hours, place it in the refrigerator uncovered and leave it overnight. This gives the layer enough density to separate from the milk beneath it and be cut with a knife.

In the morning, cut the layer into rectangular pieces with a knife and gently lift them with a spatula; the milk left underneath can be drunk separately or used in other recipes.

Why does kaymak fail to set, and what are common mistakes?

The most common mistake is stirring the milk while simmering or keeping the lid on; a covered pot prevents steam from escaping and makes it harder for the milk to thicken enough. The second mistake is using low-fat milk; in that case, a thick layer will not form no matter how many hours it rests.

The third mistake is shortening the chilling time in the refrigerator; waiting just a few hours is often not enough, and the layer needs to remain cold overnight to reach the right consistency.

The fourth mistake is moving the pot frequently or setting it down roughly; vibrations can easily break up the thin layer as it forms, so keep the pot as still as possible while simmering.

Tags
#kaymak#dairy products#homemade#consistency
Comments

Comments (2)

3.3 4 reviews 50% found it helpful 2 rated without leaving a comment
5 1
4 1
3 0
2 2
1 0
S
Selin Tekin Aide de Cuisine 6 months ago

Sütü yazınızdaki gibi 45 dakika değil neredeyse 1 saat 20 dakika kaynattım, yine de üstünde kalın bir tabaka oluşmadı; büyük ihtimalle yarım yağlı süt kullanmam sorun oldu.

F
Fatih Çelebi Aide de Cuisine 6 months ago

Sütü yazınızdaki gibi 45 dakika değil neredeyse 1 saat 20 dakika kaynattım, yine de üstünde kalın bir tabaka oluşmadı; büyük ihtimalle yarım yağlı süt kullanmam sorun oldu.

Send Feedback